Decoy Effect in Pricing: Definition and Examples in Marketing

The decoy effect in pricing occurs when consumers change their preference between two options after a third, less attractive option is introduced. For example, a coffee shop may offer a small coffee for $2 and a large coffee for $4. Introducing a medium coffee for $3.75, which is close in price to the large but smaller in size, makes the large option appear more valuable, increasing its sales. This pricing strategy leverages consumer psychology by presenting a decoy that nudges buyers toward a target product. Companies use data on sales and customer behavior to optimize the positioning of the decoy item. The decoy effect helps businesses increase revenue by boosting the purchase rate of higher-priced items without reducing perceived value.

Table of Comparison

Understanding the Decoy Effect in Pricing Strategies

The decoy effect in pricing strategies leverages a third option to influence consumer choice, making one product seem more attractive by comparison. For example, a company might offer a small coffee for $3, a large coffee for $7, and a medium coffee for $6.50, positioning the medium option as a decoy to nudge customers toward the higher-priced large coffee, increasing revenue and perceived value.

Classic Examples of Decoy Effect in Marketing

The classic example of the decoy effect in marketing is the pricing strategy used by The Economist magazine, offering a print-only subscription for $59, a web-only subscription for $125, and a combined print and web subscription for $125. The web-only option serves as the decoy, making the combined subscription appear more attractive and driving higher sales of the premium option. This strategic pricing manipulation exploits consumer preference by creating a less appealing middle option to boost the value perception of the targeted product.

Coffee Shop Pricing: The Power of the Third Option

Coffee shops often use the decoy effect by introducing a third pricing option that makes the mid-tier coffee appear more attractive compared to a cheaper small size and an expensive large size. For example, offering a small coffee for $2, a medium for $3.50, and a large for $4 creates a decoy where the medium seems like the best value. This pricing strategy influences customer choice by steering them toward the medium option, increasing overall sales and profit margins.

How Subscription Services Use the Decoy Effect

Subscription services often introduce a mid-tier plan as a decoy to steer customers towards the more expensive premium option, which offers better value per feature. For example, a streaming service might price its basic plan at $8, the premium plan at $15, and a decoy plan at $13 with limited benefits, making the premium plan appear more attractive. This pricing strategy leverages the decoy effect to increase higher-tier subscriptions and maximize revenue.

Case Study: Movie Theater Popcorn Sizes Explained

Movie theaters often use the decoy effect in pricing popcorn sizes by offering a small, medium, and large option where the medium is priced just below the large, but significantly smaller in size. This strategy nudges customers towards choosing the large size, as it appears to offer better value for only a slightly higher price. Studies show this pricing decoy increases large popcorn sales by up to 30%, enhancing overall revenue.

The Role of Decoy Pricing in SaaS Packages

Decoy pricing in SaaS packages leverages a strategically positioned middle-tier option to influence customer choice, often making the higher-priced plan appear more valuable and attractive. By introducing a less appealing package that highlights the benefits of the premium option, companies increase the perceived value of the upper-tier subscription, driving higher conversion rates. SaaS providers using decoy pricing effectively balance features and price points to guide users toward more profitable plans while enhancing overall revenue.

Supermarkets and Tiered Product Pricing Examples

Supermarkets often employ the decoy effect by placing a mid-priced product between a low-cost and a high-cost option, making the higher-priced item appear more valuable and encouraging customers to spend more. For example, a supermarket might offer a small, medium, and large coffee, with the medium priced closely to the large to nudge consumers towards the larger size. This tiered product pricing strategy leverages the decoy effect to increase average transaction value and optimize revenue per customer.

Fast Food Menus: Upsizing Through Decoy Choices

Fast food menus frequently utilize the decoy effect by offering a medium-sized option priced close to the large size, making the upsized choice appear as a better value. For example, a medium soda may cost $2.50, while a large is priced at $2.75, nudging customers to select the larger size despite the small price difference. This strategic pricing exploits consumer perception, increasing average order value by steering purchases toward the more profitable upsized items.

Decoy Effect in Electronics Retail Bundling

In electronics retail bundling, the Decoy Effect appears when a middle-tier product bundle is introduced to steer customers toward a higher-priced option. For instance, a retailer offers a basic smartphone for $500, a premium bundle with extended warranty and accessories for $800, and a decoy bundle priced at $750 lacking key features. The decoy bundle makes the $800 premium option appear more attractive, increasing its sales by leveraging comparative value perception.

How E-commerce Platforms Leverage Decoy Pricing

E-commerce platforms strategically introduce a decoy pricing option, such as a mid-tier product priced closely to a high-end alternative with fewer features, to influence consumer preference towards the more expensive choice. This pricing tactic exploits the decoy effect by making the higher-priced product appear more valuable and cost-effective in comparison. As a result, online retailers drive higher average order values and maximize revenue through subtle price differentiation.