Decoy Effect in Marketing: Definition and Practical Examples

The decoy effect in marketing occurs when a company introduces a third product option designed to make one of the original two options more attractive. For example, a streaming service might offer a basic plan for $8, a premium plan for $15, and a decoy plan priced at $14 but with fewer features than the premium plan. This strategic pricing nudges customers toward selecting the premium plan by making it appear to offer better value compared to the decoy. Retailers also use the decoy effect to boost sales of higher-margin products. A coffee shop might sell a small cup for $2, a large cup for $4.50, and a medium cup for $4.40 with slightly less coffee. The medium cup acts as a decoy, prompting customers to choose the large size due to its perceived better value, thereby increasing the average transaction size.

Table of Comparison

Understanding the Decoy Effect in Marketing

The decoy effect in marketing leverages a strategically priced third option to influence consumer choices, making one product appear more attractive by comparison. For example, a company might offer two subscription plans--basic and premium--then introduce a decoy plan priced close to the premium but with fewer features, steering consumers toward the premium option. This pricing strategy exploits cognitive biases, increasing the likelihood of higher-value purchases by subtly shaping consumer perception.

Classic Decoy Effect Example: Subscription Pricing

The Classic Decoy Effect in subscription pricing often involves three options: a basic plan, a premium plan, and a decoy plan priced close to the premium but offering less value. The decoy plan shifts consumer preference toward the premium subscription by making it appear like a better deal. This strategic pricing leverages cognitive bias to increase conversions and average revenue per user.

Decoy Effect in Fast Food Meal Bundles

Fast food chains leverage the decoy effect by introducing a mid-priced meal bundle that appears less valuable compared to a larger, more expensive option, steering customers towards the premium choice. For instance, a medium meal priced closely to a large combo nudges buyers to select the larger size for perceived greater value. This strategic pricing manipulates consumer perception, boosting sales of higher-margin products.

Electronics Retailers and the Decoy Pricing Strategy

Electronics retailers often use the decoy pricing strategy by offering three similar products where the middle option is priced close to the premium one, making the highest-priced item appear as better value. For instance, a 64GB smartphone may be priced at $700, the 128GB at $850, and the 256GB at $900, steering customers toward the $900 model as the most logical choice. This pricing decoy shifts consumer preference, increasing the average sale value while leveraging perceived cost-benefit comparisons.

Decoy Effect in Online Shopping Platforms

Online shopping platforms often implement the decoy effect by presenting three product options where the middle-priced item serves as a decoy to make the higher-priced product appear more attractive. For instance, a streaming service might offer a basic plan at $8, a premium plan at $15, and a slightly upgraded plan at $14.50, directing consumers to choose the premium plan by making it seem like better value compared to the decoy.

Beverage Brands Leveraging the Decoy Effect

Beverage brands often use the decoy effect by introducing a mid-priced drink option to steer consumers toward a higher-margin premium product. For example, Coca-Cola might present a small, medium, and large size with the medium priced close to the large, making the large size appear as the best value. This pricing strategy strategically nudges customers to choose more expensive beverages, increasing overall sales revenue.

Decoy Pricing in Travel and Airline Ticket Options

Decoy pricing in travel and airline ticket options manipulates consumer choice by introducing a third, less attractive option to steer customers towards a more profitable or premium ticket. For instance, airlines often present three fare classes: economy, premium economy, and business class, with premium economy priced close to business class but offering fewer benefits, making business class appear more valuable. This pricing strategy leverages the decoy effect to increase sales of higher-margin tickets by shifting perceived value without altering the core product offerings.

Decoy Effect in Restaurant Menu Design

Restaurants use the decoy effect by introducing a mid-priced menu item that makes a higher-priced option appear more attractive, increasing sales of premium dishes. For instance, offering a $15 pasta, a $25 steak, and a $22 chicken dish encourages customers to choose the $25 steak due to perceived value. This pricing strategy leverages consumer psychology to shift preferences toward higher-profit items without reducing overall customer satisfaction.

E-commerce Upselling with the Decoy Effect

E-commerce platforms leverage the decoy effect by offering three pricing tiers where the middle option is strategically priced to make the most expensive tier appear more valuable, encouraging customers to upgrade. For example, a basic subscription at $10, a decoy option at $25 with fewer benefits than the premium $30 plan, nudges users towards choosing the higher-priced premium plan. This pricing strategy increases average order value and boosts upselling success.

Enhancing Brand Perception through Decoy Marketing

Offering a premium product as a decoy can elevate consumer perception of a brand by making mid-tier options appear more valuable and affordable. This strategy leverages comparative pricing to nudge customers toward choosing higher-margin products, reinforcing a sense of quality and exclusivity. Brands like Apple effectively use this by positioning high-end devices to enhance the appeal of their standard offerings.